Updated For 5.4 Mists of Pandaria

Gem Quality

Color Popularity Gem Quality Auction Price
Red/Blue 6 star Guardian's Imperial Amethyst
+160 Expertise and +120 Stamina
Rare
Red/Blue 5 star Accurate Imperial Amethyst
+160 Expertise and +160 Hit
Rare
Blue 4 star Rigid River's Heart
+320 Hit
Rare
Blue 4 star Solid River's Heart
+240 Stamina
Rare
Yellow/Blue 3 star Lightning Wild Jade
+160 Haste and +160 Hit
Rare
Red/Blue 3 star Shifting Imperial Amethyst
+80 Agility and +120 Stamina
Rare
Blue 3 star Stormy River's Heart
+160 PvP Power
Rare
Red/Blue 2 star Glinting Imperial Amethyst
+80 Agility and +160 Hit
Rare
Yellow/Blue 2 star Effulgent Wild Jade
+80 PvP Power and +160 Mastery
Rare
Blue 2 star Perfect Solid Lapis Lazuli
+240 Stamina
Rare
Blue 2 star Stormy Lapis Lazuli
+120 PvP Power
Uncommon
Yellow/Blue 2 star Piercing Wild Jade
+160 Critical Strike and +160 Hit
Rare
Red/Blue 2 star Shifting Roguestone
+60 Agility and +90 Stamina
Uncommon
Blue 1 star Rigid Lapis Lazuli
+240 Hit
Uncommon
Yellow/Blue 1 star Sensei's Wild Jade
+160 Hit and +160 Mastery
Rare